Public Records
Elmira pays Flock $100,000 a year for plate cameras that mostly flag suspended registrations
Elmira, New York kept its Flock license plate cameras on a five-year contract as Ithaca, Tompkins County and Syracuse dropped theirs. Of 17,838 alerts in the last 30 days, 97 percent were for suspended or revoked registrations.
Elmira, New York pays Flock Safety $100,000 a year for 40 license plate cameras, and in the 30 days before Nov. 16, 97% of the alerts those cameras sent officers were for cars with suspended or revoked registrations.
The five-year contract, which the city released in response to a FinePrint records request, was signed by Mayor Daniel J. Mandell Jr. in February 2024 after the city council approved it 4-1. Councilman Nick Grasso, the lone no vote, said at the time he had seen no data showing the cameras worked. The city pays $2,500 per camera per year, and the $505,000 total includes a $5,000 fee, $500 for each of the 10 cameras Elmira cut from its original 50. When the five years are up, the contract renews for two more unless either side opts out at least 30 days ahead. Federal pandemic relief money paid for Elmira's first Flock deal in 2022; city payment records show the 2026 bill came out of the general fund in March.
The contract covers more than the city's own cameras. Elmira officers can look up plates on any Flock camera in the state or the country that has opted into Flock's statewide and nationwide networks, see privately owned Flock cameras that businesses or neighborhoods share with police, and get an alert when a car listed in the FBI's NCIC crime database passes a camera.
Those alerts come from hotlists, lists of plates the cameras flag automatically. Elmira's Flock transparency portal shows 148,108 plate reads and 17,838 alerts over the last 30 days. Two state lists of suspended or revoked registrations, which returned nearly identical counts, produced 17,335 of them. Stolen plates and vehicles accounted for 342 alerts and wanted people for 152. The department's posted policy bars using the system for traffic or immigration enforcement and requires an officer or 911 dispatcher to confirm a hit before anyone acts on it.
Elmira shares its camera data with 124 organizations, all in New York except one Pennsylvania county detectives' office. No federal agency is on the list.
A November 2024 amendment made the city the owner of the hardware. Under it, Elmira holds title to each camera from installation and pays to replace any that are damaged. When the contract ends, the city sells each one back to Flock for $1.
Elmira's neighbors have gone the other way. Ithaca's council voted unanimously in March to end its Flock contract, citing the city's sanctuary policy, and the Tompkins County Legislature followed in April. Syracuse revoked its contract the same month as Ithaca after learning its police had opted into Flock's national sharing network.
Elmira's full record, including its other surveillance tools, is on Accurint Files.
Document
Primary Source
muckrock.com
View document →
Newsletter
Findings and features, in your inbox.
New findings and monthly features from the FinePrint newsroom. Free, no spam, unsubscribe anytime.
Delivered by Substack.
Related Articles